Swampie's Blog - Latest Comments in Win with Style

Re: Win with Style

swampie — Tue, 03 Nov 2009 16:13:18 -0000

There is no way you can compare the two in my opinion. A tremendous dual threat quarterback to a great great runningback? Ask yourself this with Tebow's opportunities how many more yards would he have gained had he been able to run like Walker? And had Walker been able to throw like Tebow and complete as many TD passes and as few INTs how many more holes in the dropback pass or shotgun would he be able to take advantage of? It's mind boggling to me. But there is no way the two can be compared. One thing that must be address is if you count bowl game TDs now they must be counted back then, that rule makes no sense whatsoever. Correct that and Tebow still has a record to break.

Re: Win with Style

Bill — Mon, 02 Nov 2009 11:21:12 -0000

Swampie:
No one in Gator Nation respects H. Walker more than I do. I can remember watching him run and the only comparison of amazement I can think of is watching Tiger Woods hit shots when the pressure is on. I watch to be amazed. However, Tim broke his record, I hear comparisons and that there should be an * denoting differences, 4yr vs 3yr QB vs RB etc. It occured to me that you have often done some good objective analysis in comparing difficult things, ie apples and and oranges. This would be a good project. # of carries/TD Career-to-date(CTD), average yards/carry CTD; I'm sure you can think of more areas that would be of interest. just a thought Thanks Bill